Comprehension Questions

    "The Numbing of the American Mind" - Thomas de Zengotita

    1. Explain how the Nietzsche epigraph connects to Zengotita’s argument.

    2. Summarize the point in each of the following sections: Fabrication, Flood, Finitude, Fast, Moving On.

    3. Discuss the following quotes:

    “Someday, it will be obvious that all the content on our information platforms converges on this theme: there is not important difference between fabrication and reality . . . “

    “Our minds are the product of total immersion in a daily experience saturated with fabrication to a degree unprecedented in human history.”

    “Conditioned thus relentlessly to move from representation to representation, we got past the thing itself well; or rather, the thing itself was transformed into a sea of signs and upon it we were borne away from every shore, moving on, moving on. What else could we do?”

    4. Identify two passages that you feel are important to the article or that you would like the class to discuss.

    Read More...

    Malcolm Gladwell - “Thresholds of Violence”

    1) Consider Gladwell's introduction.  Why does he introduce the essay with a long narrative?  What point does he make with his introduction?

    2) Immediately after the introductory narrative, Gladwell uses the listing technique.  What is the point he makes with the list?

    3) On page four, Gladwell asserts his first explicit claim.  What is it?

    4) How does Gladwell develop this claim?

    5) Identify Granovetter’s research question and his conclusions.

    6) How does Gladwell apply Granovetter’s riot or threshold theory to school shooters?

    7) John LaDue’s story is woven through the long essay.  What point does Gladwell emphasize through this narrative?

     

    Did you find this resource helpful?  If so, please leave a comment!  Your feedback means a lot to me!

    Read More...

    Sherry Turkle - "Stop Googling. Let's Talk."

    1) What is Turkle’s thesis?

    2) What does Turkle see as the connection between conversation and empathy?  Why does Turkle distinguish a difference between “old conversation” and "new conversation"?

    3) Why does Turkle think solitude is important?  What is the difference between solitude and loneliness?

    4) List the three steps Turkle offers to help make face-to-face conversations a priority.

    5) What is the “app generation”?  How is Turkle connect this concept to empathy?

    6) Identify at least one of logos, ethos, and pathos appeal in the essay.

    7) Evaluate the evidence Turkle uses to support one of her claims.

     

    Did you find this resource helpful?  If so, please leave a comment!  Your feedback means a lot to me!

    Read More...

    Sherry Turkle - "The Flight from Conversation"

    1)  What is Turkle's thesis idea?
    2)  What specific changes in human behavior does Turkle suggest result from our use of electronic devices?
    3)  Why does Turkle think conversation is preferable to "sips" of online connnections? Provide at least three reasons.
    4)  What is Turkle say about solitude?
    5)  Do you agree with Turkle's argument?
    6)  Consider the many ways our society uses technology.  List at least ten.  Then choose one idea and write a paragraph about what changes in society that technology has brought about--the changes can be positive, negative, or both.

    Read More...

    Diane Ravitch - "American Schools in Crisis"

    1. How does Ravitch spark interest in her introduction?

    2. Why does Ravitch provide a brief history (from the 1840s to current day) of public schools?

    3. List two problems Ravitch sees in the No Child Left Behind legislation.

    4. Describe Ravitch's main problem with Race to the Top.

    5. According to Ravitch, what evidence supports the policies of NCLB and Race to the Top?

    6. Name one of Ravitch's criticisms of charter schools.

    7. What does Ravitch believe is the primary cause of poor student performance?

    8. What problem does Ravitch see with voucher programs?

    9. Describe what Ravitch sees as the "fork in the road" in America’s pursuit to improve student achievement.

    Read More...

    Garrett Hardin – “Lifeboat Ethics”

    1)  Explain Hardin's lifeboat analogy to foreign aid.

    2)  What is "the tragedy of the commons"?  List the types of commons Hardin sees.

    3)  How does Hardin see the World Food Bank as a "commons in disguise"?

    4)  Why does Hardin see the success of the Green Revolution as an "irrelevant point"?

    5)  List a few instances of Hardin’s use of slanted language.

    6)  Consider Hardin’s target audience.  What values, beliefs, and assumptions about foreign aid do you think 1974 readers of Psychology Today held?

    7)  Chart the skeletal structure for one of Hardin’s main claims.  Then evaluate the evidence he provides to support that claim.

    Evaluation of Evidence

    TS

    S

    S

    S

    8)  Summarize Hardin’s thesis and main claims (topic sentence claims).

    9)  Describe Hardin’s tone.  Does it help build his credibility?

    10)  Locate one of Hardin’s counterpoints and assess how well he handles it.  Does he help or hurt his credibility by his treatment of the counterpoint?

    Read More...

    Jonathan Rauch – “Will Frankenfood Save the Planet?”

    1)  Consider how Rauch chooses to frame his argument.  What is the singular lens through which he views genetically modified foods?  (To answer this question, you might want to list some to the arguments you’ve heard for and against GM food and then compare that list to the argument Rauch makes.)

    2)  Who is Rauch’s target audience?  Generally, what can you surmise about how readers of The Atlantic view GM food?

    3)  What values, beliefs, and assumptions do you think Rauch’s target audience holds about GM food?

    4)  Chart Rauch’s skeletal structure.  Then explain how each of Rauch's main claims appeals to the values, beliefs, and assumptions of his target audience.

    _______________________

    Thesis:

    Pathos appeal within thesis
    ___
    TS:

    Pathos appeal within TS
    ___
    TS:
    Pathos appeal within TS

    _______________________

    Finally, why do you think Rauch presents the order of his claims as such?

    5)  Assess Rauch's strategy of sticking to audience-based reasons.  Do you think it enhances his argument?  Limits it?

    6)  Describe Rauch’s tone.  Does it help build his credibility?

    7)  Identify two areas where Rauch anticipates the counterpoint.  Do you think he effectively refutes each one of them?

    8)  Choose one of Rauch’s main claims and locate his support for the claim.  Evaluate the support using STARR criteria.

    9) Identify and evaluate three pathos appeals.

    Read More...

    Amanda Ripley - “Who Says a Woman Can’t Be Einstein?”

    Answer questions 2, 3, 5, and 7 on pages 514-515.

    2.

    3.

    5.

    7.

    Read More...

    Michael Pollan – “Playing God in the Garden”

    1)  Explain what Pollan means by, “[t]his convenient version of reality” in the third paragraph.  How does it explain American ambivalence toward GM foods? How does it explain Europe’s resistance to GM foods?

    2)  Pollan writes that organic farmers, conventional farmers, agribusiness corporations, government officials, and environmentalists agree that the industrial food chain needs reform.  Why do all stakeholders agree that the current model of industrial farming unsustainable?

    3)  Explain Pollan’s point in each of the following sections: Sprouting, Growing, and Flowering.

    4)  What is Pollan’s implied argument about the safety of bioengineered foods and the U.S. regulatory system (the USDA, FDA, and EPA)?

    5)  Who are the metaphorical “beetles” in the section “Meeting the Beetles”?  What does each of these beetles represent?

    6)  What is Pollan’s implicit argument about the sustainability of organic farming?

    7)  What does Pollan see as the real problem facing farmers?

    8)  Finally, identify Pollan’s thesis and the main claims he uses to support his thesis.  Remember, these may be implied.

    9)  Describe Pollan’s tone.  Does it help build his credibility?

    10) Identify and evaluate three pathos appeals.

    11)  Choose one of Pollan’s main claims and locate his support for the claim.  Evaluate the support using STARR criteria.

    12) How does the genre help guide the depth and rhetorical choices Pollan makes in the piece?

    Read More...

    Steven Pinker - “In Defense of Dangerous Ideas”

    1)  How does Pinker define a dangerous idea?

    2)  What historical examples does Pinker offer to suggest that “ intellectual intimidation . . . inevitably shapes the ideas that are taken seriously in a given era”?

    3)  List the three perceptions of “dangerousness” that Pinker develops in his essay.

    4)  Describe the two types of dangerous ideas that Pinker wants explored.

    5)  List Pinker’s reasons for exploring dangerous ideas (at least two or three).

    6)  List the reasons for not exploring dangerous ideas that Pinker offers (at least three or four)

    Read More...

    Tangey, Kahan, and Stryker

    1) Explain what Tangney sees as the distinction between shame and guilt.
    2) Why does Kahan support the use of shame as an alternative to imprisonment?
    3) Describe Stryker's stance on public shaming.

    Read More...